The Defects of Samsara

Most of us spend a surprising amount of time looking for a place to land. An experience that will finally be enough. A situation that will not shift under us. A solution that will keep dissatisfaction from showing up again. The fourth of the four thoughts that turn the mind is a reflection on why that search keeps going. In the traditional language it is called the defects of samsara. The point is not to adopt a new set of beliefs about other realms. It is to notice, in our own experience, how the assumption of a lasting fix keeps us circling, and how seeing that more clearly can turn the mind toward the causes of freedom.

Each of these reflections has a specific way of helping us see something new about ourselves, life, and the world. They also evoke particular qualities when we work with them. As with most of the dharma, we approach them through learning, reflection, and meditation. When something feels difficult or unclear, that is often a sign we need to study a little more. Reflection is where we work out disagreements, biases, and questions about whether the teaching is valuable. The goal is not to believe something. It is to use the reflection to deepen our experience of reality and of the dharma, and to grow more of a sense of exhaustion with the causes of suffering.

These four thoughts sit inside a more traditional presentation of the dharma. After many years of studying, reflecting on, and meditating with them, I have found them useful both in formal practice and in ordinary life, in how I meet delusion and destructive emotions. The process takes time. We go at our own pace. There is no rush. It is simply a matter of keeping an open mind rather than installing a new belief system right away.

In Buddhism as a whole, the emphasis is not on belief in and of itself. We already have plenty of beliefs. The work is to understand why we believe what we believe, to draw out faults or fallacies, and to deepen what is true. The same applies here. A spiritual path can look at first like a set of beliefs. It is more useful to treat it as a set of prompts for seeing how the mind works, how the causes of suffering and the causes of happiness operate, and how the causes of suffering can be removed. Some of the traditional descriptions are difficult to prove empirically or to make sense of immediately. That is fine. We can take them at a pace that is sane, keep an open mind, and allow some skepticism. Skepticism turns into solid doubt only when we stop learning and inquiring. These reflections work as prompts for inquiry.

What samsara is

Samsara can be explained plainly or more profoundly. The deeper aspects often become visible only after we have worked with what is easier to see. One definition is simply to circle. That circling appears in the traditional description of birth again and again in the six realms. There is a kind of hierarchy among the realms, yet the main point is the circling itself, the never-ending movement and the not knowing how to get out. We circle among states of existence, among various kinds of dukkha, primarily because we remain confused about the causes of freedom and the causes of suffering.

For those of us who have a strong allergy to anything outside what we can see or perceive, there is another way to approach it. Samsara can be thought of as circling moment to moment in not knowing where to land. We do not know where solid ground is, where we can put our feet, where the rug will not be pulled out from under us. This can appear as unconscious clinging to permanence. Something changes dramatically and we are thrown off, unsure how to recover. It happens to all of us. There is nothing wrong with you or me for it. It is simply a mechanism of samsara.

Another expression is the ordinary fact of change and unwanted things happening, along with the lack of control. We cannot control suffering or dissatisfaction. That is frustrating for most of us, and a lot of us are constantly seeking an out from it, whether we notice or not. A useful first place to look is whether we are always seeking something else. We have an enjoyable experience and it is not enough; we want it again or we want more. We are satisfied for a while and then become dissatisfied and want something different. Or we dislike an experience and look for ways to avoid it, get away from it, or solve it.

I am not saying we should stop trying to solve problems or improve our lives and the lives of others. The point is the mechanism of seeking a solution in itself, the assumption that there will be an ultimate solution where we never again experience dissatisfaction, pain, or heartbreak. That is a delusion. It is something we need to discover for ourselves through reflection. This is the more inner side of the defects of samsara, and it is where I want to focus. The outer reflection on the realms is usually the traditional starting point, yet for modern seekers it can feel like someone is trying to force a religious fantasy. We can reorder the process and begin with the inner work. At some point it is still useful to turn back toward the outer representation. Just because we do not believe something, or think it is fantasy, does not mean it is untrue.

The six realms

I will name the six realms briefly before returning to the inner reflection. Two of them we can see, and one we have direct experience of. The human realm contains a vast array of experience: highs and lows, godlike wealth and pleasure, and hell-like hunger, pain, and war. The animal realm is considered slightly below the human in the traditional ordering. This is not a judgment that animals are unworthy or less deserving of care, nor permission to dominate them. The hierarchy has to do with the capacity of the body and mind to practice dharma. The animal realm is far larger than the human one. It includes not only pets but wild animals, insects, fish, and trillions of sea creatures. There is no clear count, and that is only this world.

The three higher realms are the human realm and the two kinds of deva realms. Deva is difficult to translate. It points to godlike beings rather than a single theistic God. The closest Western parallel is the Greek and Roman gods. One deva realm has form, a body or light body. The other is formless, mind only. These higher states can be reached through concentration meditation that accumulates the corresponding karma. The three lower realms begin with the animal realm. Next is the preta realm, often translated as hungry ghost. These beings are not generally visible. They are not animals and not ghosts in the ordinary sense. They experience extreme difficulty obtaining food and shelter, with intense problems of heat and cold, and inability to eat or drink properly. The suffering is great enough that practicing dharma and liberating oneself is extremely difficult from within that realm.

The last of the lower realms is the hell realms. For people who grew up with Judeo-Christian teachings in which hell was used as a punishment technique, this can be triggering. In Buddhist cosmology the hells are not eternal. There are traditionally eight hot hells and eight cold hells, with the primary suffering related to heat or cold, along with peripheral hells. Extremely harmful actions can ripen as birth in these realms, and the time spent there can be very long. If they exist, we do not want to end up there, and we do not want anyone else to end up there. The suffering is extreme, with no capacity even to hear the word dharma or kindness.

In the human realm we can already see versions of these experiences: hellish conditions, animal-like conditions, and deva-like conditions. The main reason for reflecting on the realms is to create an exhaustion with existence itself. By existence I mean a self embodied in a place where we are confused and unable to discern the causes of freedom from the causes of suffering. We are not seeking non-existence; that is not possible. For most modern meditators this outer material is a difficult starting place, so it is fine to begin with the inner work and return later. Incorporating these reflections was not easy for me over the years. It also brings in the question of rebirth, which can be contentious. I do not like being pushy about it. We need to see the benefit of the practice before it is useful; otherwise it can create more resistance or, for some people, more trauma.

Three types of dukkha

One of my favorite ways into the defects of samsara is through the three types of dukkha. Dukkha is a Sanskrit and Pali word that points to more than ordinary suffering. It includes pain, dissatisfaction, confusion, and delusion. Fundamentally it is the confusion that binds us to samsaric existence and to the circling described earlier. That circling appears moment to moment in craving and aversion, or in fear and expectation. The important part is investigating it for ourselves, because then we naturally want to turn the mind toward practice and toward working with the mind and afflictive emotions in a wholesome way.

Dukkha is the status quo of samsaric existence. Whatever realm we are in, it is present, though the form and intensity differ. The three types cover most of what can be experienced within samsara. We reflect on them not to feel worse, not to dwell, and not to become more religious. We use them as prompts to see whether they are true. If we begin to see some truth through direct experience, we will want to remedy dukkha, which is one of the primary teachings of the Buddha in the Four Noble Truths.

The dukkha of dukkha is the most straightforward. It includes everything we label as undesirable, from a serious illness to a bagel that does not come out of the toaster properly. The range is wide. The dukkha of change is more interesting. The fact that things change is not itself the problem; impermanence is actually useful. The dukkha of change has to do with craving, with the assumption inside an experience that it will provide the lasting pleasure or outcome we want. When we look carefully, the opposite appears. Pleasure declines the more we engage with something. A classic example is sitting and standing. After sitting a long time the body begins to hurt, and standing brings relief. After standing long enough the wish to sit arises, and sitting again brings the same “ah, finally.” Nothing quite remains satisfactory. This depends on the aggregates of body and mind embedded in samsara, along with conditions, yet most of us can relate to it.

Taken into practice, this reflection bursts the bubble of finding a place to land. What is unique in the dharma is that there is no other solution we are going to find. The work is to resolve the solution-mentality itself. When that loosens, we can discover the open, spacious nature that was never touched by dukkha. Experience can move through it. I often have to remember why I am doing the reflection. If I am only thinking that the second bite of ice cream will be less satisfactory than the first, the point is easy to miss. The point is not to be attached to the ice cream, because less craving means less suffering. It does not mean I have to stop eating ice cream. The fundamental problem is not the thing. It is how we are interacting with it. Dharma offers many pathways for changing that interaction. This is one of them.

The third type, all-pervasive dukkha, is even more subtle. Seeing the dukkha of change already requires some capacity to notice the mind engaging in craving. The classic description of all-pervasive dukkha points to the five aggregates. Once body and mind have come together at birth, the situation is pervaded by dukkha because unwanted experiences, including birth, old age, sickness, and death, are inevitable. That can sound dire, so a shift in vantage point helps. I prefer a description from Mingyur Rinpoche: an underlying discontent that is almost imperceptible, the sense of never feeling quite at ease or quite okay. At some point we need to do something else, to move, to begin another activity. We can enjoy relaxing for a long stretch of the day, yet eventually restlessness appears. This is one way all-pervasive dukkha is described. It pervades experience so that we never quite feel okay.

That is the difficult news. The good news is that this is not our nature. Reflecting on what is not our nature can lead toward our nature. That is one way the dharma works. A reflection on dukkha is not simply a prolonged bummer. It helps us see the causes of dukkha more clearly so we can begin to move away from them. The all-pervasive form is especially tough because, while we have a sense of self, of I, me, and mine, we vacillate between wanting something and then tiring of it and wanting something else.

A short reflection

A simple way to practice is to meditate primarily on the dukkha of change. Take a relaxed yet alert posture for about five minutes, alternating between analytical investigation and resting. Use the breath or any other anchor to settle into the present moment. Bring in a motivation to see the truth, even if that truth proves someone else wrong or proves you wrong. The wish to see how things are comes from care and warmth for ourselves and others.

Bring to mind a time when you stood or walked for a long stretch and then sat down. Recall the relief of sitting. Ask whether that was satisfactory and sufficient. Did you sit and never need to get up again? Imagine sitting long enough that the body becomes tight or heavy and you have to move. When a little recognition lands in the body, drop the investigation and stay with the sense that nothing is quite perfect. The reflection can arouse sadness or relief. Either is fine. Simply be with what arises. You can return to gentle investigation and then rest again. Close by returning to the anchor and dedicating the energy so that seeing the truth of reality may uncover more compassion, openness, freedom, and awakening for yourself and others.

This is only one short example. The other two types of dukkha can be worked with in the same way, formally on the cushion or informally in daily life. I often watch the dukkha of change when I am excited about something. I am not trying to ruin the excitement. I simply want to see how things are rather than stay stuck in a fantasy. I watch the mind with the ice cream, or the walk, or finally sitting on the couch. From this we learn a great deal about ourselves and about the mind. Primarily we learn that samsara is an inside job. It is not about fixing everything outside us, or about everyone else being screwed up. We are seeing through our own perception. We are not fundamentally screwed up, yet there are obscurations that prevent us from encountering our openness, our compassion, and a more liberated way of being.

What these reflections keep showing is that samsara is an inside job. The circling is not primarily out there in the world or in other people. It is in the way perception keeps looking for a solid place that will not be pulled out from under us, and in the way that search itself produces more of the dissatisfaction we are trying to escape. Seeing that does not require believing every traditional detail of the six realms or the cosmology. It does ask us to look carefully at how craving, change, and a subtle underlying discontent actually operate in ordinary experience. When that looking is honest, the exhaustion with the causes of suffering is no longer an idea. It becomes something we can feel, and from there the mind has a clearer reason to turn toward what actually frees it.

Scott Tusa

Scott Tusa is a Buddhist meditation teacher and practitioner who has spent the last two decades exploring how to embody and live meaningfully through the Buddhist path. Ordained by His Holiness the Fourteenth Dalai Lama, he spent nine years as a Buddhist monk, with much of that time engaged in solitary meditation retreat and study in the United States, India, and Nepal. Since 2008, he has been teaching Buddhist meditation in group and one-to-one settings in the United States, Europe, Latin America, and online, bringing Buddhist wisdom to modern meditators, helping them develop more confidence, inner wisdom, and joy in their practice.

https://scotttusa.com
Next
Next

Karma Without the Cosmic Scoreboard